Keystone Cold Cases

Episode 18: Steven Whitenight Jr. - Missing (2016) AND Perry County Jane Doe (1979)

In the early morning hours of January 14, 2016, a white 1997 Ford Probe was found near the Bloomsburg Municipal Airport. The keys were in the ignition, but no one was in the car.  A set of footprints led halfway across the snow covered bridge over the Susquehanna River. What happened at the end of those footprints? Listen as Grace explains the story and Amanda, Chelsea, and Sarah comment. Stay tuned to the end to hear Sarah talk about "The Girl with the Turquoise Jewelry" found skeletonized in Perry Co. PA in 1979. Sources and photos can be found on our website: kccpod.com

Episode 17: Ray Gricar: Missing (2005)

The Centre County DA goes missing, leaving only his car in a publicly frequented parking lot. Where did Ray Gricar go? Who caused him to disappear? Why was he off work when he went missing? Do you know what happened? Listen in as Amanda explains the story and theories to Chelsea, Grace, and Sarah.  Sources and photos can be found on our website: kccpod.com 

Episode 16: Maria Cabuenos & Julie Barnyock - Murdered (1997/1993)

Two women are murdered in the Philadelphia area nearly 4 years apart.  Could their cases be connected?  And how many other cases could potentially be linked to theirs as well?  Listen as Chelsea shares the details of the two women's stories and discusses theories with Amanda, Grace and Sarah.  Sources and photos can be found on our website: kkccpod.com 

Episode 15: The Boy in the Box - Unidentified (1957)

Content Warning: Child Case; Child Abuse; Sexual Assault. In late February 1957, a bassinet box was found in Fox Chapel just outside of Philadelphia. Also known as “America’s Unknown Child”, the case of “The Boy in the Box” remains unsolved to this day, and the identity of this child remains unknown, for now. Listen in as Sarah describes the case and discusses theories with Amanda, Chelsea, and Grace. All sources and additional information are available at kccpod.com. 

Episode 14: Sarah Rae Boehm - Murdered (1994)

On July 15, 1994, 14 year old Sarah Rae Boehm walked out of her Rochester Township home and never returned.  Her remains were found near Deerfield Township, Ohio on November 4, 1994, but they were not officially identified until nearly 9 years later. Listen in to hear Grace tell the details of this case, while discussing theories with Amanda, Chelsea, and Sarah. As always, find all of our sources and additional information (including an analysis of the letter mentioned in this episode) at kccpod.com

Episode 13: Ryan Stevyn Benjamin - Murdered (2016) AND Penny Doe - Unidentified (1990)

TWO CASES TODAY :: Today, join the KCC crew as they tell the stories and discuss the theories behind two PA cases. First, Chelsea will tell the story of Ryan Stevyn Benjamin, a NY native found 5 years ago this month in a pond. Then, Grace will detail everything that's known about an unidentified woman known only as Penny Doe who was discovered over 20 years ago. Amanda and Sarah join in with discussions for both cases. For more details on this and all of our other episodes, visit kccpod.com! 

Episode 12: David Hurley - Murdered (1992)

Also referred to as the case of the PA Route 22 killer, this episode covers the case of David Hurley. David Hurley was a father, baseball coach, and was headed to help out on a boy scout trip when he was shot 3 times after a minor accident. Was it random, planned, or drug related? Listen as Amanda tells the story and discusses theories with Chelsea, Grace, and Sarah. 

Episode 11: The Babes in the Woods - Murdered (1934)

On November 24, 1934, the bodies of 3 young girls, ages 8, 10, and 12, were discovered lifeless, tucked under a blanket, laying in a field near Pine Grove Furnace State Park. On November 25, 1934, over 100 miles away near Altoona, PA, a man and his niece are found dead of an apparent murder-suicide. Who are these people and how are these two crimes connected? Listen as Sarah tells the story and Amanda, Chelsea, and Grace discuss their thoughts and theories. 

Episode 10: Beth Lynn Barr - Murdered (1977)

Beth Lynn Barr was born on December 20, 1970 to Charles and Donna Barr.  Less than a month shy of her 7th birthday, in November 1977 Beth was abducted while walking home from school after an early dismissal before Thanksgiving break.  Less than two years later her body was found in a shallow grave on the edge of a cemetery, about 6 miles from where she was taken. Listen in as Grace tells the story and discusses theories with Amanda, Chelsea, and Sarah.  

Episode 9: Robert Baron - Missing (2017)

When the daily dough delivery for the Ghigiarelli’s Pizzeria was found on the sidewalk, Robert's family knew something was wrong. They had no idea they would be walking into the restaurant to find signs of a violent assault and Robert still missing. Listen as Chelsea tells the story and discusses theories with Amanda, Grace, and Sarah.